Did Aristotle Fail in Physics? Part 4

I'm on to Premise B and why Feser, Crane, and Jaki confuse me.

Hi, welcome back to my crazy. This is going to get detailed, but I hope you follow and let me know your thoughts. As a reminder, I use this Substack sometimes to write about writing, like I did with that philosophy thesis on elements. I’m working on a paper now for the International Congress on Science and Faith honoring Stanley L. Jaki in His Birth Centenary (1924-2024). The conference is held at the CEU Universidad San Pablo on October 22-26, 2024. Um…in one week! My paper is titled, “Jaki on Aristotle’s Failure in Physics.” I chose that topic because I want to get to the bottom of some confusions I came across while reading Jaki, Aristotle, Aquinas, Feser, and Crane. I’m also working out my method for continuing my work on elements in a dissertation.

This post will begin the examination of Premise B.

Here’s the argument again from Part 1:

Premise A—>An organismic world view causes a failure in physics. (Part 2, 3)
Premise B—>Aristotle held an organismic world view.
Therefore, Aristotl…