Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kanyimbe Ker's avatar

Great article! I'm a Christian also trying to engage atheist arguments as charitably as possible. Looking forward to learning more from you.

Expand full comment
Aaron Schuck's avatar

Consider first, the delineation of belief as defined within the Catholic tradition. Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, inculcated that the crux of the Christian belief starts from a humble acceptance of God's existence. From this divine acquiescence flows a stream of faith, morality, love, and inherent meaning, all emanating from this primal conviction. However, we must be reminded of Ratzinger's emphasis on the pursuit of open dialogue and understanding as indispensable companions of faith, most notably highlighted in his seminal text "Introduction to Christianity.” For him, faith starts with God but should engage with the doubts and questioning present in modern thought, a lesson applicable here in our exploration of atheism.

To grasp the seemingly heterogeneous nature of atheistic beliefs, one must untether the concept of belief from its theistic confines. While theism (and Christian belief in particular) usually accommodates a central guiding principle i.e., God and His divine teachings, atheism, as explained by Oppy, does not hinge on an opposite single antithesis. Instead, it makes room for an amalgamation of beliefs drawn from various sources such as reason, methodology, empirical evidence, personal experience, and ethical standards.

What can be discerned as a guiding principle in an atheist's life is perhaps an ardent reliance on reason and empirical evidence. They seek answers to the existential and moral enigmas in the natural world and human experience, despising any appeal to divine or supernatural entities or principles. The rational inquiry becomes their compass, leading their pursuits in life. Inspired by this view, many atheists place crucial importance on ethical living, social justice, and the pursuit of knowledge, showing that a life without belief can, nonetheless, be rich with purpose and moral integrity.

However, this explanation should not oversimplify or stereotype the diversity that exists within atheism, just as one would err in stereotyping the various expressions of belief within Christian tradition. Atheism is not a singular, monolithic viewpoint but a large tent accommodating various perspectives - a spectrum rather than a distinct point. Therefore, just as diverse spiritual charisms express themselves within a Christian framework, so too does a variety of outlooks find shelter under the umbrella of atheism.

Even the teachings of the Second Vatican Council in "Nostra Aetate" recognize the validity of different paths to truth and encourage respect and dialogue among diverse belief systems. While retaining the belief in the salvific mission of Christianity, the Church also acknowledges that “truths found among non-Christians can work to God’s glory,” implying that an atheist's pursuit of truth, too, can be a journey towards a greater understanding.

This exploration incarnates Ratzinger's own theological method - deep historical-contextual understanding, a harmonious merging of tradition with modern reflection, balanced examination of the issue, and a commitment to further learning. The heart of Ratzinger's theological method invites an atheist-Christian dialogue that can foster mutual understanding and challenge each side to deepen their beliefs through interaction with the other. Let us continue to build bridges of understanding and respect in our shared pursuit of truth. For, as Ratzinger reminds us in "Truth and Tolerance", "the truth can only be a network of relationships, a shared journey, an open-ended process."

In my opinion, it would be easier to covert an aethiest or your modern day progressive hippy type to Catholicism than Non-Catholic Christian.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts